lightreads

Any Way the Wind Blows

4/5. Continuation of the series begun with Carry On. The first book was magic school adventure with heavy Harry/Draco vibes to the queer romance. The second book was post school U.S. road trip with dysfunctional established relationship (don't ask me anything else about it, I read it three weeks after Casterbrook was born and have close to zero memory of it). This one is much more functional established relationship back home with bonus plot about what it is to be chosen and unchosen and the young adult struggle to find oneself in the wreckage of a war and betrayals. Also, there is a cute F/F subplot involving goats that I enjoyed, even though it didn't quite have enough space to breathe.

She left enough lose ends here to support another book, and I'm still here for it. There's a lot of we're together and now the hard work starts to this book, which is squarely my jam, and I am not sick of these two being sarcastic and deeply devoted. The plot is exactly what you think it is from the first inkling, and the twist at the end is thoroughly telegraphed, but eh, I'm not really here for that stuff.

Wayward Son

3/5. Sequel to her Carry On, which is an AU version of the fantasy series that her characters write fanfiction about in another book, like you do. This is nice – it is breaking more definitively away into its own lane since it is post school and there isn't a Harry Potter book to get snagged on pointlessly comparing it to. This is an American road trip book with magical shenanigans and relationship drama. However, be warned that this is not a sequel, it's a series continuation and resolves close to nothing that I cared about. This was a surprise to me – unpleasant since I was like "….hey," at the end, pleasant because there is clearly going to be at least one more book.

Fangirl: A Novel

3/5. The story of Cath's first year of college. She has an anxiety disorder, and her twin isn't talking to her, and she has lots of work to do on her slashy fanfic magnum opus, oh and there's this boy….

Aw man, this book was so hard to read because reading about anxious people makes me super anxious. But don't let my issues stop anybody else, because this is awesomesauce. Actually, more accurately, this is so fucking truefax. Cath's struggles with writing original fiction, the intensity of her feelings for her fanfic, the beautiful way this book creates intimacy between people by having them share fanfic read aloud . . . yeah. Been there.

I love the way this book is about slash. It's just part of who Cath is, and some people get that and some people don't. And if the reader doesn't, well, whatever, basically. There are excerpts sprinkled throughout from Cath's WIP and her older work, and from her canon book, and they made me facepalm and chortle in turn. Cath's writing is that awkward but compelling stuff that an eighteen-year-old with genuine talent will turn out . . . and that will horrify her a decade later. Yes, also been there, thanks.

My only objections are (1) that I was utterly uninterested in the romance here. Just . . . nothing; and (2) Cath's fannishness is oddly isolated. She doesn't seem to have real online friends, just fans, which is a little weird.

But if it's a young adult book that normalizes and validates fannish behavior you want, then here you go, this is a good one.

Carry On

4/5. Simon Snow is in his last year at British magic boarding school. He has a prophecy about him, and more power than any ten mages, and a mortal enemy to fight, and also the lesser enemy of his roommate. Who at some point he starts inadvisably making out with.

So everyone keeps saying that this is the book that Cath in Fangirl writes fic about; that is totally not true, as this book does not match in style or content the excerpts we get in Fangirl. In truth, this is a grownup version of the fanfic story Cath writes; grownup because this is clearly tighter and more mature than Cath's eighteen-year-old style.

So really, this book is the AU version of the slash fanfic that a character in another book writes about a different fantasy series that doesn't exist. Got that? Great.

I liked this. People are being predictably obnoxious about the Harry Potter analogs, because it is 2015 and we are still not over denigrating transformative works, not even close. And yeah, this book owes a lot to Harry/Draco fanfic. This book owes a lot to Harry Potter fandom at large. That’s the thing about it – this book isn't really about Harry Potter. It's about Harry Potter fandom, which is an entirely different and more extraordinary beast. This book is about those esthetics, emotional and stylistic. About my esthetics, I realized halfway through, because I grew up in Harry Potter fandom, and in a fundamental way, reading a book about the hero of the magical world falling in love with another boy is like coming home.

Also, it's a young adult novel that is getting marketed as much for its fantasy elements as for its queer romance (and by "marketed for queer romance" I mean shoved in the queer romance ghetto, obviously). So there.

S	M	T	W	T	F	S
1	2	3	4	5	6	7
8	9	10	11	12	13	14
15	16	17	18	19	20	21
22	23	24	25	26	27	28
29	30

Entries tagged with au: rainbow rowell

Any Way the Wind Blows by Rainbow Rowell

Wayward Son by Rainbow Rowell

Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell

Carry On by Rainbow Rowell

Profile

June 2025

Syndicate

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags