![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Team of Rivals
And on the topic of skinny dudes from Illinois who get elected President . . .
Man. Nine hundred firm, densely-researched, elegant pages on Lincoln and his cabinet, focusing on the political rivals he turned into friends because, well, he was not kidding when he said "with malice towards none." It's a book about leadership – how to get people to do what you need them to do when they don't want to while treating them with respect and courtesy. Though really, I can just shorthand to say it's a book about getting people.
I really like what Goodwin does here. She's the sort of historian who lets you see her hands nearly the whole time, but in that calm, measured way where she's just holding up these people for you to look at, not pinching their cheeks and primping them up first. Lincoln has been a particular historical darling for the past few decades, and I'm really not immune. This book is unsentimental nearly all the time, and it moved me a great deal. And not just because I was thinking about comparisons – presidents who write, presidents who orate, presidents who believe in consensus without believing implicitly in centrism. I was making those comparisons, though.
And on the topic of skinny dudes from Illinois who get elected President . . .
Man. Nine hundred firm, densely-researched, elegant pages on Lincoln and his cabinet, focusing on the political rivals he turned into friends because, well, he was not kidding when he said "with malice towards none." It's a book about leadership – how to get people to do what you need them to do when they don't want to while treating them with respect and courtesy. Though really, I can just shorthand to say it's a book about getting people.
I really like what Goodwin does here. She's the sort of historian who lets you see her hands nearly the whole time, but in that calm, measured way where she's just holding up these people for you to look at, not pinching their cheeks and primping them up first. Lincoln has been a particular historical darling for the past few decades, and I'm really not immune. This book is unsentimental nearly all the time, and it moved me a great deal. And not just because I was thinking about comparisons – presidents who write, presidents who orate, presidents who believe in consensus without believing implicitly in centrism. I was making those comparisons, though.
no subject
Date: 2008-11-17 03:13 am (UTC)While I would love the comparisons to be true, I'm not at all yet convinced that all skinny President-elects from Illinois are equally good. But it does cheer me that Lincoln really didn't have much experience, and people really did worry about whether he'd do a good job.
no subject
Date: 2008-11-22 03:52 am (UTC)