Living Promises by Amy Lane

[lightreads]

Living Promises by Amy Lane

My rating: 3 of 5 stars


M/M modern romance of her usual 'make lots of melodramatically bad things happen to these people and stick a wedding at the end' variety. I can't think of another M/M dealing with HIV off the top of my head, so there's that. And I did like this in a distracted, way-more-important-shit-going-on-give-me-a-book way. Even with all the emotional breakdowns and nonsense.

But – and I realize I sound like a broken record here – but. This genre does not understand homophobia. According to this genre, there are two kinds of people: there are homophobes who disown their queer children in dramatic fashion, and then there's everyone else who isn't homophobic. Riiiight. I mean, those homophobes do exist. But writing about that is writing the most cartoonishly villainous face of it, and entirely missing the grinding, subtle, every day corrosion. You know, the complicated parts. Like how a friend's mother gave the old family silver to the straight daughter and not the queer daughter because – and mom didn't articulate this or probably even know – because the straight daughter had the sort of family/table on which ancestral silver belongs, and the queer daughter and wife did not. When the M/M genre defines homophobia only by violence and blatant hate, it fails to get its hands around some fundamental truths of what it is to be queer. And also perpetuates homophobia, but it does that in a hundred other ways too, so.

I'll stop bitching about this eventually.




View all my reviews

Comments

[batdina]

According to this genre, there are two kinds of people: there are homophobes who disown their queer children in dramatic fashion, and then there's everyone else who isn't homophobic.

I haven't a clue about this book or this author, and as such I also haven't a clue about the publisher of the book. That said, one of the most frustrating things about a lot of M/M publishing houses terms for submission, is that they don't allow homophobia. As in they won't permit writers to use negative words about gay people, or even to portray anything negative about being gay in the real world.

I remember editing a novel for someone and being told that she couldn't do what I was suggesting because _________ publishing house didn't allow it.

And I'm with you, the resulting pap frustrates the hell out of me.

[lightreads]

I believe it. Though it's a good bet not all of the bigger m/m publishers go that way, just based on some Josh Lanyon titles. Then again, he's a big name so....