Okay, so, first, can I say how much I LOVE your book-review-rants?

Also, I am very sad, because this sounded very very much like something I would like to read, until your last paragraph. Because you know how I feel about pop science. GAH. I NEED CITES.

I might read it anyway, though, it sounds that good in all other respects (I'd really like to see the takedown of evolutionary psychology, which honestly I don't know much about), and just prepare to beat my head against the wall a lot when I want to see data...